Search pghbridges.com
Search WWW




Historic American Engineering Record
"Three Sisters" Bridges
HAER No. PA-490



(Trinity of Bridges)
Pennsylvania Historic Bridges Recording Project - II
Spanning Allegheny River at Sixth, Seventh, and Ninth streets
Pittsburgh
Allegheny County
Pennsylvania





Previous Page

THREE SISTERS BRIDGES
HAER No. PA-490
(Page 36)

clearance, which was 14'-0" and 12'-0" less than the bridge's height. After supporting the bridge under the floor beams, they disassembled the top chord and stabilized each panel point on the trusses. [151]

Steering the bridge under the Manchester Bridge and the railroad bridge at Brunot's Island, the tugboat captains went through the Ohio River lock and up the back channel toward Coraopolis, where piers and abutments had been constructed. Reversing the process and using the same jacks and steel frames to raise the structure 32'-0", the company erected the Cooper bridge 30 days after the project began. [152]


Completing the Sixth Street Bridge

Work proceeded on the new Sixth Street Bridge, with the Foundation Company called to accept last-minute revisions of piers 1 and 4 to accommodate subway construction at a later date. Bion J. Arnold's influential transportation report called for converting street-level areas downtown to pedestrian and automobile use. He recommended building tunnels for subways to connect Pittsburgh's central business district with selected areas, including the North Side. Although business owners and city officials hotly contested the exact route for such a system, the North Side access required by any future subway system was not in doubt. [153]

The revisions proposed constructing tunnel shields that could be pierced when the city decided on a final route. The tubes were 68'-0" on center, with suggested radii ranging from 7'-9" to 9'-0", and steel reinforcement overhead. One proposal for the construction shows plans using three separate open box caissons to form the base of each pier. [154] The tube openings provided slightly different angles for each direction to adapt to the grades and length of approaches on north and south shores, anticipating lines that bent outward to avoid the two main piers. The city of Pittsburgh absorbed the cost of the alterations to the original plan, paying the Foundation Company the same contract costs negotiated for the bridge work of up to $40,000 for the south pier and $80,000 for the north pier. [155] (The subway openings have yet to be used, however. Pittsburgh's underground light rail system, constructed between 1980 and 1985, follows a Sixth Street alignment for several blocks but does not cross the river.)

----

[151] ACDPW, "Floating Intact."

[152] ACDPW, "Floating Intact."

[153] Arnold, Report.

[154] "Scheme B, Suggested Plan for Using Three Separate Open Box Caissons for Base of Each Pier," 23 Aug. 1926, in Files AL 02-04, ACDPW.

[155] City of Pittsburgh, to Allegheny County, regarding articles of agreement for construction work on the south pier and abutment of the Sixth Street Bridge and the north pier and abutment of the Sixth Street Bridge, in File AL 02, ACDPW. See also Drawings No. 287 and 297 (23 Nov. 1926), in Files AL 02-04, ACDPW.




THREE SISTERS BRIDGES
HAER No. PA-490
(Page 37)

Even with the subway alterations, the Foundation Company completed its work four months ahead of schedule, leaving to the American Bridge Company a working schedule during Pittsburgh's bitter winter weather. The company continued to fabricate components at its Ambridge shop, completing two-fifths of the 6,000 tons needed while it waited for better river conditions. In the meantime, workers pre-assembled smaller components off site. Brown's office justified the apparent delay in a press release, responding to business owners who insisted that work continue amidst the winter by noting no contractor could reasonably be expected to erect the side-span falsework necessary for the project with the dangerous currents and ice faced by the American Bridge Company. The uniqueness of a suspension bridge erected by cantilever methods required exceptional caution. [156]


Conclusion

Its predecessor razed in September 1924, the Seventh Street Bridge was the first completed. The county opened the Seventh Street Bridge on 17 June 1926, and the Ninth Street Bridge on 26 November of the same year. County commissioners soothed area business owners anxious for a return to normal commerce by allowing pedestrians to use the Sixth Street Bridge's downstream sidewalk on 14 September 1928, in advance of the bridge's official opening. In a move that symbolized commitment to keeping its public works promises, the capstone of Allegheny County's 1924 construction program was brought to a close almost exactly four years after workers began tearing down the first of the three bridges. The Sixth Street Bridge was opened to all traffic on 19 October 1928. [157]

The county's public works projects in the 1920s employed local labor instead of contracting with outside consultants or companies, and materials were procured from area manufacturers. "Every pound of the thousands of tons of steel used in our bridges was manufactured in the mills of our district," Armstrong wrote in his re-election campaign literature in 1931. He reminded voters that he had helped oversee the construction of ninety-nine bridge projects at a cost of $47.2 million Included in the list were the Coraopolis Bridge, at Neville Island in Coraopolis Borough in 1928, costing $0.8 million; the Sixth Street Bridge in 1928, $1.5 million; the Seventh Street Bridge in 1926, $1.4 million; and the Ninth Street Bridge in 1926, also $1.4 million. Significant in themselves, the bridges were only part of a massive $31 million construction plan beginning in 1924 and ending in 1931. Armstrong boasted, "More county

----

[156] Carbon copy of memo,"New 6th Street Bridge," n.d., in File AL 02, ACDPW.

[157] Plowden, Bridges, 239; "Ninth St. Bridge Formally Opened," Pittsburgh Chronicle Telegraph, 26 Nov. 1926, in Clippings File, Pittsburgh Bridges -- Ninth Street, Pennsylvania Room, Carnegie Library, Pittsburgh, Pa.; "Parade Marks Sixth Street Span Opening," Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 20 Oct. 1928, in Clippings File, Pittsburgh Bridges -- Sixth Street, Pennsylvania Room, Carnegie Library, Pittsburgh, Pa.; and "Opening of the Sixth Street Bridge Sidewalk, Friday, September 14, 1928, 4:00 P.M. Daylight Saving Time," press release from Norman F. Brown's office (12 Sep. 1928), in File AL 02, ACDPW.




THREE SISTERS BRIDGES
HAER No. PA-490
(Page 38)

improvements were made during this 8 year period than during the previous 136 years of the county's existence. [158]

One of Armstrong's pieces of campaign literature, a lavishly illustrated brochure, prominently featured an aerial view of the "Trinity of Bridges" overlaid with a photo of American Institute of Steel Construction's 1928 award to the Sixth Street Bridge. [159] AISC named the structure "The Most Beautiful Steel Bridge" constructed in 1928, adding to the fame of the Allegheny County Department of Public Works and publicizing the potential of steel for enhancing not only strength but attractiveness One of five judges, Charles Evan Fowler, commented on the choice of winners:

The new Sixth Street Bridge at Pittsburgh was selected because in my opinion it combined the essential elements of beauty, simplicity, symmetry, harmony, and proportion, and also because of its originality of design, it being a self anchoring eye-bar cable suspension bridge. The cables have enough section to give a very satisfying appearance of stability, combined with simplicity of construction. The towers are very chaste in design, yet heavy enough to give every appearance of strength and solidity. The large arch over the roadway is surmounted by an unequal number of portal openings, yet very harmonious with the entire design of the towers, and the graceful curve of the cables. [160]

The award enhanced the city's image as a forward-thinking municipality with an economy based on a material of the future, but the bridges also healed friction that had festered between business interests in former Allegheny City and Pittsburgh since the mid-nineteenth century. Roush noted, "As has already been expressed by some business interests on the north side of the river, 'There is a feeling that a barrier had been removed between the two business sections of the City.' " [161] The Three Sisters Bridges embody not only a unique construction method and design but also a specific response to local and national political configurations. The structures represent a larger process of social conflict and cohesion that began half a century before, as well as advances in material technology and design that became available only within the decade of its construction.

----

[158] "8 Eventful Years, 1931 campaign brochure for Joseph G. Armstrong, in James D. Van Trump Library, Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, Pittsburgh, Pa.

[159] Armstrong, "8 Eventful Years."

[160] "The Artistic Bridge: 1928 Award, 1929 award brochure from American Institute of Steel Construction, Inc., New York, in File AL 02, ACDPW.

[161] Roush, "Sixth, Seventh and Ninth St.," 196.




THREE SISTERS BRIDGES
HAER No. PA-490
(Page 39)

SOURCES CONSULTED

Published

Allegheny, city of. Municipal Reports for the Fiscal Year Ending February 28th, 1898. Allegheny, Pa.: T. A. McNary, 1898.

____. Municipal Reports for the Fiscal Year Ending February 28th, 1899. Oil City, Pa.: Derrick Publishing Company, 1899.

Arnold, Bion J. Report on the Pittsburgh Transportation Problem. Pittsburgh: City of Pittsburgh, 1910.

Baldwin, Leland D. Pittsburgh: The Story of a City. Pittsburgh: Univ. of Pittsburgh Press, 1937.

Briggs, Adrian J., comp. A Chronological History of Old Allegheny City Penna. Pittsburgh: Don Kuhl Printing Co., 1969.

Church, Samuel Harden. Short History of Pittsburgh, 1758-1908. New York: DeVinne Press, 1908.

Covell, Vernon R. "The Bridge-Raising Program on the Allegheny River in Allegheny County." Proceedings of the Engineers' Society of Western Pennsylvania 41 (1925): 81-104.

____. "Erecting a Self-Anchored Suspension Bridge -- Seventh Street Bridge at Pittsburgh." Engineering News-Record 97 (1926): 502-05.

Cramer, Zadok. The Navigator: Containing Directions for Navigating the Monongahela, Allegheny, Ohio and Mississippi Rivers.... 8th ed. Pittsburgh: Cramer, Spear & Eichbaum, 1814. Reprint, Ann Arbor, Mich.: University Microfilms, Inc., 1966.

Darnell, Victor C. A Directory of American Bridge-Building Companies 1840-1900. Occasional Publication No. 4. Washington, D.C.: Society for Industrial Archaeology, 1984.

Everts, L. H. & Co. History of Allegheny Co., Pennsylvania. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott & Co., 1876.

Harper, Frank C. Pittsburgh of Today: Its Resources and People. Vol. 1. New York: The American Historical Society, Inc., 1931.

Harrington, John Lyle. "Recent Developments in Bridge Superstructures," in Proceedings of the Engineers' Society of Western Pennsylvania 46, No. 3 (1930): 52-76.

Heller, A. H. Stresses in Structures and the Accompanying Deformations. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1908.

Herbertson, Elizabeth T. Pittsburgh Bridges. New York: Exposition Press, 1970.

Hool, George A., and W. S. Kinne. Movable and Long-Span Steel Bridges. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1923.




THREE SISTERS BRIDGES
HAER No. PA-490
(Page 40)

Hopkins, G. M. Atlas of the Cities of Pittsburgh and Allegheny, from Official Records, Private Plans and Actual Surveys. Philadelphia: G. M. Hopkins, 1882.

____. Atlas of the County of Allegheny, Penna., from official Records, Private plans and Actual Surveys. Philadelphia: G. M. Hopkins, 1876.

Jerman, D. T. "Moving the 440' Truss Spans of Sixth St. Bridge, Pittsburgh.'' Engineering News-Record 98 (1927): 850-851.

Kaufman, Gustave. "The Reconstruction of Ninth Street Bridge, Pittsburg, Pa." Proceedings of Engineers' Society of Western Pennsylvania 8 (1892): 189-226.

Kelly, J. M. Handbook of Greater Pittsburgh. 1st ed. Pittsburgh: J. M. Kelly, 1895.

McCullough, C. B. Economics of Highway Bridge Types. Chicago: Gillette Publishing Co., 1929.

"The New Sixth Street Bridge, Pittsburgh, Pa." Railroad Gazette (28 July 1893): 560.

Olmsted, Frederick Law. Pittsburgh Main Thoroughfares and the Downtown District: Improvement and Future Needs. Pittsburgh, 1911.

Petroski, Henry. Engineers of Dreams: Great Bridge Builders and the Spanning of America. New York: Alfred A. Knopf 1995.

Plowden, David. Bridges: The Spans of North America. New York: W. W. Norton & Co., 1974.

Roush, Stanley L. "The Sixth, Seventh, and Ninth Street Bridges, Pittsburgh, Pa." American Architect 133 (1928): 191-196.

Pittsburgh Chamber of Commerce. Special Committee on Free Bridges. Report of Committee on Free Bridges. Pittsburgh, 1911.

Steinman, D. B. A Practical Treatise on Suspension Bridges: Their Design, Construction and Erection. 1st ed. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1922.

____. A Practice Treatise on Suspension Bridges: Their Design, Construction and Erection. 2nd ed. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1929.

____. Suspension Bridges and Cantilevers: Their Economic Proportions and Limiting Spans. 2nd ed. New York: D. Van Nostrand Co.,1913.

Strobel, C. L. "A New Truss Design and Its Analysis." Engineering News 38 (1897): 51-52.

"The New Sixth Street Bridge, Pittsburgh, Pa." Railroad Gazette 25 (1893): 560.

"Three New Allegheny River Bridges to be of Unusual Type." Engineering News-Record 93 (1924): 995 97

Tyrrell, Henry Grattan. History of Bridge Engineering. Chicago: self-published, 1911.




THREE SISTERS BRIDGES
HAER No. PA-490
(Page 41)

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. List of Bridges over the Navigable Waters of the United States. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1926.

U.S. War Department. Opinion of the Secretary of War in re Elevation of Bridges over the Allegheny River at Pittsburgh. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1917.

Van Trump, James D., and Arthur P. Ziegler, Jr. Landmark Architecture of Allegheny County Pennsylvania. Pittsburgh: Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, 1967.

Waddell, J. A. L. Economics of Bridgework: A Sequel to Bridge Engineering. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1921.

Warner, A. & Co. History of Allegheny County, Pennsylvania. Vol. 1. Chicago: A. Warner & Co., 1889.

Watson, Wilbur J. "Bridge Architecture." Proceedings of the Engineers' Society of Western Pennsylvania 46, No. 3 (1930): 77-94.

White, Joseph, and M. W. von Bernewitz. The Bridges of Pittsburgh. Pittsburgh: Cramer Printing & Publishing Co., 1928.

Wilkins, W. G. "The Reconstruction of the Sixth Street Bridge at Pittsburg, Pa." Proceedings of the Engineers' Society of Western Pennsylvania 9 (1895): 143-67.


Unpublished

Aurand, Martin. "Allegheny County Owned River Bridges Thematic Resource," Allegheny County, Pennsylvania. National Register of Historic Places Registration Form, 1986. U.S. Department of the Interior, National Park Service, Washington, D.C.

"Bridges: List of the Bridges, authorized by the Legislature of Pennsylvania, to be erected by companies, in the order in the several acts of incorporation were passed," Pennsylvania State Archives, "Allegheny Bridge Company at Pittsburgh, 1824-46," Records of the Department of the Auditor General, Internal Improvements File, Pennsylvania State Archives, "Bridge Co. Accounts, 1809-1859," General Administrative and Financial Records, RG-2: Department of the Auditor General.

"8 Eventful Years," campaign brochure for Joseph G. Armstrong, Allegheny County Commissioners' Election of 1931. File 43 -- Public Works -- Series I -- Print Collection, Drawer 4, Cabinet IV, James D. van Trump Library, Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, Pittsburgh, Pa.

Farrington, P. M., S. J. Fenves, and J. A. Tarr. The Allegheny County Highway and Bridge Program 1924-1932. Report No. R-82-132. Master's thesis, Carnegie-Mellon Univ., 1982.




THREE SISTERS BRIDGES
HAER No. PA-490
(Page 42)

Greater Pittsburgh, 22 Dec. 1928. Pittsburgh Chamber of Commerce. Pittsburgh -- Allegheny County -- Public Works file, Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, Pittsburgh, Pa.

Pittsburgh, City of. "Incorporation of Boroughs and Townships Now Annexed to City," 1936.

Closed Reference Map Files, Pennsylvania State Library, Harrisburg, Pa.

Pittsburgh First, 6 Dec. 1924, Pittsburgh Chamber of Commerce. Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pa.

Richardson, George S. "History of Allegheny County Bridges: An Oral History of the Bridge Construction Program from April 1924 to March 1937 Inclusive." Interview by Steven J. Fenves. File 54: Bridges -- I -- Lists, Collected Descriptions, Pictures, Drawer 1, Cabinet IV, Print Collection, James D. van Trump Library, Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, Pittsburgh, Pa.


Archives Accessed

Allegheny County, Department of Public Works, Records Division, Pittsburgh, Pa. Bridge inspection reports, construction drawings, and photographs.

Archives of Industrial Society, Hillman Library, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pa. City Photographer's Collection and Fort Pitt Bridge Works Collection.

Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pa. Pennsylvania Room.

City of Pittsburgh, Department of Engineering and Construction, Bridge Division, Pittsburgh, Pa. Bridge inspection reports and vault drawings files.

Henry Heinz Regional History Center, Pittsburgh, Pa. Archives of the Western Pennsylvania Historical Society.

Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Harrisburg, Pa. National Register of Historic Places files.

Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, Pittsburgh, Pa. James D. Van Trump Library Collection and Post Card Collection.

Pennsylvania State Archives, Harrisburg, Pa.

Pennsylvania State Library, Harrisburg, Pa.




First Page

Page created:
Last modified: 05-May-2003

HAER Text: Haven Hawley, August 1998; Pennsylvania Historic Bridges Recording Project - II
visit site - "American Memory" at Library of Congress
visit site - National Park Service -- Historic American Engineering Record